【United Kingd】Is Quantum Technology More Important Than Artificial Intelligence (AI)?

Editor’s Note

This article explores the inherent challenge of communicating quantum concepts, a field where precision and accessibility often seem at odds. It examines how this complexity intersects with the rise of artificial intelligence.

一个女人手持晶片
The Quantum Conundrum and the AI Spotlight

There’s an old saying among tech journalists: you can either explain quantum accurately or make it understandable, but you can’t do both.

This is because quantum mechanics—a peculiar and partly theoretical branch of physics—is an incredibly difficult concept to grasp. It involves the bizarre behavior of tiny particles, and this strangeness opens up a whole new realm of scientific superpowers.

The breathtaking complexity of quantum mechanics might be one reason it hasn’t captured the spotlight like today’s tech star, Artificial Intelligence (AI), despite major quantum announcements from tech giants like Microsoft and Google.

Broadly, we often think of quantum technology in terms of hardware like sensors and computers, while AI leans more towards software—which needs hardware to run. Combining the two might one day yield technology more powerful than anything before.

However, Brian Hopkins, Vice President and Principal Analyst of Emerging Technology at research firm Forrester, warns that the word “might” in that prediction carries significant uncertainty.

“The potential is there, but the ultimate outcome is still unknown,” he said. “Early experiments show promise, but all indicate we need more powerful quantum computers and more innovative research to effectively apply quantum effects to AI.”
Value, Hype, and Common Challenges

In terms of value, both are highly attractive. Market research firm McKinsey predicts the quantum sector could be worth up to $97 billion (£74 billion) by 2025. Meanwhile, AI’s value is projected to reach trillions of dollars. Yet both are shadowed by hype and potential bubbles.

“I used to think quantum computing was the most hyped technology, until the AI boom came along,” Mr. Hopkins quipped.

In mid-October, analysts warned that some key quantum computing stocks could fall by up to 62%, while discussions about an AI bubble also increased.

Quantum computing and AI share another commonality—errors. While we’re now familiar with the “hallucinations” of generative AI tools, quantum computing faces a different kind of error. These errors occur because particles must be in an extremely fragile state; even the slightest environmental change, including light and noise, can disrupt it.

Maintaining this state is very difficult. This week, Musk stated on X that quantum computing is best suited for “permanently shadowed craters on the moon.”

The Form and Future of Quantum Machines

Quantum computers look completely different from traditional ones. There’s no single design blueprint yet, but they are all very large. They exist in labs, most commonly resembling jellyfish in form. They require extremely low temperatures and lasers—not something likely to appear in homes, let alone pockets.

They also have a touch of luxury—researchers have found that using synthetic diamonds to create qubits (the basic building blocks of quantum computers) can allow them to operate closer to room temperature. Element 6, a subsidiary of luxury jeweler De Beers, claims to have launched the world’s first universal quantum-grade diamond in 2020 and is collaborating with Amazon Web Services (AWS) to optimize lab-grown diamonds for future quantum computer networks.

These machines are still in their infancy, with only about 200 believed to exist worldwide (though China has not disclosed its numbers)—but that hasn’t stopped quantum experts from making bold predictions about their potential.

“As consumers, we will feel the impact of quantum computing in almost every aspect of our lives,” said Rajeeb Hazra, CEO of Quantinuum, a quantum computing company recently valued at $10 billion, in an interview with the BBC’s Tech Life podcast. “In my view, the scale of applications in the quantum computing field is at least as large as, if not larger than, that of AI.”
Prof Sir Peter Knight, one of the UK’s leading quantum experts, told Dr. Jim Al-Khalili on BBC Radio 4’s The Life Scientific: “Calculations that would take the age of the universe on the most powerful supercomputers could potentially be done in seconds.”
Transformative Applications: From Medicine to Navigation

So, what life-changing transformations can these machines bring once they are ready? Like AI, a significant amount of quantum research is dedicated to improving healthcare. Future quantum computers might easily process countless molecular combinations to develop new drugs—a process that currently takes years with traditional computers.

To illustrate the scale, Google released a new quantum chip named Willow in December 2024. Google claims the chip can solve in five minutes a problem that would take the world’s fastest supercomputer “10 to the power of 25” years (i.e., 10,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 years).

Hazra said this could pave the way for personalized medicine, where patients receive drugs tailored to their individual body chemistry, most likely to be effective, rather than standard prescriptions.

This also applies to broader chemical processes, such as new methods for producing chemical fertilizers more efficiently, which could greatly benefit global farmers. Quantum sensors, which use the principles of quantum mechanics for extremely precise measurements, already exist and are used in atomic clocks.

In 2019, scientists at the University of Nottingham integrated a quantum sensor into a prototype device the size of a bicycle helmet for a new system of non-invasive brain scans for children with conditions like epilepsy.

“The foundations of human cognition are laid in the first few decades of life, but we have struggled to study them in depth due to the limitations of brain scanning technology,” researcher Ryan Hill said at the time. “A particularly tricky issue has always been movement, as traditional large, fixed scanners always require patients to remain completely still. This not only fails to accurately reflect how the brain operates in a natural environment but also severely limits who can be scanned, with children facing the greatest challenges.”

Last year, scientists at Imperial College London trialed an alternative to GPS satellite navigation called a “quantum compass” on the London Underground network. GPS doesn’t work in the subway, but this system can—the idea is to track and locate objects worldwide more precisely, whether above or below ground, as GPS signals are susceptible to blockage, interference, and weather.

“The UK economy relies on GPS for £1 billion worth of positioning, navigation, and timing every day—often considered a defense need—but all our financial transactions require timestamps for authentication,” said Dr. Michael Cuthbert, Director of the UK’s National Quantum Computing Centre. “Using quantum clocks, gyroscopes, and magnetometers, we can enhance the resilience of critical navigation systems against interference and spoofing.”

National Grid is investing in quantum technology research to explore whether it can help solve the so-called “load shedding” problem—how to maximize the output of thousands of generators from different energy sources based on real-time demand fluctuations to avoid blackouts.

Additionally, Airbus is collaborating with UK quantum technology company IonQ to test quantum-based algorithms aimed at loading cargo onto aircraft more efficiently. A slight shift in an aircraft’s center of gravity can cause it to consume thousands of kilograms of extra fuel.

The Looming Threat: Quantum and Encryption

So far, so good—but we also need to talk about secrets. It is widely believed that existing encryption—how we store personal data and state secrets—will eventually be broken by quantum technology, which can cycle through all possible combinations in an extremely short time until the data is decrypted. It is known that countries have already begun stealing each other’s encrypted data, hoping to decode it one day.

“It’s called ‘harvest now, decrypt later’,” said Prof Alan Woodward, a cybersecurity expert at the University of Surrey. “The theory for breaking existing public-key encryption awaits the arrival of truly functional quantum computers,” he added. “The threat is so great that there is a broad consensus that post-quantum encryption needs to be introduced now.”

The moment such computers arrive is sometimes called “Q-Day.” Estimates vary on when quantum encryption-breaking might arrive, but Forrester’s Brian Hopkins suggests it could be soon—around 2030.

Companies like Apple and the secure messaging platform Signal have already released what they believe are post-quantum encryption keys, but these keys cannot be retroactively applied to existing data encrypted in traditional ways. And this is already a problem. In October last year, Daniel Shiu, former head of cipher design at GCHQ, the UK’s intelligence, security, and cyber agency, told The Sunday Times that “almost all UK citizens’ data may have been compromised in Chinese state-sponsored cyber attacks,” and this data has been collected, awaiting the day it can be decrypted and studied.

一幅艺术家绘制的画面:一只小型、绿色、背部覆有毛绒的恐龙,站在后腿上,在一棵树的根部附近啃食地上的叶子
Full article: View original |
⏰ Published on: November 07, 2025