Editor’s Note
This article explores the surprising variety of jewelry available at thrift stores, from costume pieces to valuable finds, and explains how these items often get there.
Elizabeth says that thrift stores can truly be a goldmine for jewelry lovers, noting that you can easily come across fun and colorful costume jewelry, and if you dig a bit deeper, you can even stumble upon fine jewelry, vintage engagement rings, or designer items.
Beautiful jewelry pieces that end up at thrift stores can come from someone’s personal closet or may have been donated from an estate.
Elizabeth says that she’s always on the hunt for vintage earrings, from clips to hoops to vintage studs.
Along with other standard items like necklaces and bracelets, Elizabeth says that vintage rings are commonly found as well.
And from what eras do these jewelry pieces hail from? In Roseveare’s experience, she seems to find more contemporary and vintage jewelry rather than antique jewelry at thrift stores. If these types of items sound right up your alley, it’s time to get thrifting.
Elizabeth says that familiarizing yourself with various jewelry materials ahead of shopping can pay off. For this, you’ll need to make sure you can spot real gold or silver by viewing the markings, such as “14K” or “925” if they were made in the United States, or “750” or “1000” if it was made in Europe or Asia, as Elizabeth details.
Also, know how to look for more specialized materials that grab your interest. For example, if you love the look of Bakelite “plastic” jewelry from the 1940s and ’50s, learn the differences between Bakelite and reproduction Bakelite. For instance, you can rub a Bakelite piece with your finger to create friction and heat, and if there is a faint musty, chemical odor, it’s more than likely the real deal.
She shares a story, saying that recently she has been on the lookout for vintage Elsa Peretti jewelry.
Translation? Do your homework and learn about the looks and histories of jewelry pieces you particularly love.
In Roseveare’s experience, she has found “better items” in the glass case next to the cash register, versus items out on a counter or shelf.
Roseveare recommends bringing along a jeweler’s loupe when you go thrifting. These pocket-size magnifying glass feature an illuminating feature that can help you see the cut, color, and clarity of stones, as well as tiny stamps and signatures, with ease.
Elizabeth says that it’s a good idea to look for designer signatures, such as YSL and Chanel with markings inside, on jewelry pieces.
This is another reason why it’s a wise idea to take a jeweler’s loupe with you on your thrifting outings.
Nowadays, you don’t necessarily have to thrift in person to discover those sought-after jewelry pieces. Roseveare points out that Goodwill sells jewelry online, with some available to purchase now and some that can be bid on. Other sites, like Chairish, eBay, and 1stDibs are also excellent resources to find antique, vintage, and luxury jewelry.
